Which came first, the payment or the expense?
As of May 21, 2018, according to the website: https://turbotax.intuit.ca/tips/are-medical-expenses-deductible-5317 (image above) they recommend paying large medical expenses in advance in order to claim a tax credit in the year you paid.
This is not entirely accurate.
Payment alone will not guarantee that you can claim it as a medical expense.
In an (originally issued in French) external interpretation issued by the Canada Revenue Agency on December 6, 2016 (2015-0589041E5 F) they clarified that prepayment of medical services only works for services consumed in the 12 months ended in the tax year.
Relying on a 2001 Federal Court of Appeal case, the CRA stated,
“an expense is “incurred” […] only where there is an obligation to pay a sum of money. […] we are of the view that a fee paid is not necessarily an expense incurred. This could mean that it is to be regarded as a prepaid fee. With respect to an amount paid for medical expenses, it must, therefore, be determined whether it is an expense incurred or a prepaid amount.”
They are saying that there is a difference in the tax treatment between prepayment and an expense, which is why we have to figure out what the payment is.
It seems to say that if there were no services rendered, then it isn’t an expense.
Think of the following scenario:
– Your child goes back to school in the fall.
– You find out they need braces.
– After some back and forth and budget planning you decide to go ahead.
– The orthodontist in this example gives you payment options: pay up front or set up a payment plan (usually a higher amount overall).
– You make the voluntary decision to pay upfront before installing the braces.
– You pay the fee in late November in the tax year, but the braces are not installed until January of the following year.
To this extent the CRA continues:
“…medical expenses [for a particular taxation year must] have been paid within any period of 12 months that ends in the taxation year…”
The CRA continues by stating that an individual can choose any 12-month period in the year, but the expenses must be paid in that period.
“Thus, for the purposes of computing the METC, it is necessary to determine whether the expenses paid […] were paid during the period chosen by the taxpayer.”
So yes, we paid during the period, but the CRA is using that word expenses, and we already know that they don’t call it an expense unless services are rendered
This means since no services were rendered in the tax year, we cannot claim the prepayment as an expense (or at least according to them).
The ruling gets worse.
If you are like most people, you submit your receipts on a calendar year to your accountant and don’t give it much more thought than that.
The CRA states how you could lose the deduction entirely:
“where an individual chooses the period from January 1 to December 31 [of the taxation year] the expenses that are the subject of the METC computation must have been paid during the same period.
For example, if a dental service is rendered on January 15 [of the taxation year] […] and the expenses are incurred at that time, the fees paid for that service would be medical expenses […]
If these fees were paid on December 31, [of the previous year] they would not be eligible for the METC computation for [the taxation year] as they would not have been paid during the selected period.”
Yes, they are saying that if you prepaid for medical services, the amount held on deposit at your orthodontist’s office would not be considered expenses – even as the services are rendered – if the payment was not in the 12-month period reported on the return.
So not only did you not get the expense in the tax year that you prepaid but because you filed your medical expenses on the calendar year, you don’t get the medical expense when the services were rendered either because there was no payment in the year.
They do provide a little hind-sight relief, however, but it requires more filings subject to their approval (which is never a quick process). Simply put, they state that in this scenario, they would let you go back to amend the earlier tax year to include the expense.
Personally speaking, this is frustrating because when you file the first year, they are saying it is not eligible, but after you file the second year, they tell you to go back and amend the first year.
Seems like semantics, as the braces won’t be installed on your child unless you are both bound to some sort of contract including requirements to pay but watch for an over-zealous tax auditor to kick out your deposit in year one if services were not yet rendered especially where the deposit is refundable.
In order to please the CRA, it is my suggestion that when you make the prepayment – rather than just getting your credit card slip and a statement of account showing the deposit – you need to have some sort of written contract or agreement with the medical practitioner’s office. This agreement should state that the prepayment is for medical services to be rendered by the practitioner and is non-refundable and that you have an “obligation to pay” prior to services being rendered.
Hey… I didn’t say it was a GREAT recommendation… and most things to appease the rules in the Income Tax Act aren’t.
One Eleven Grill shows off new renovations and some new menu creations
One of Red Deer’s favourite restaurants has put some major effort into updating their space and creating some new menu items. One Eleven Grill opened its doors in 2011 with as a fresh and innovative entry into the local dining scene.
They’ve recently completed renovations and spent considerable time and effort developing some tasty new menu items. Watch the video above to get an idea of what you’re in store for next time you head down to one of the city’s finest restaurants.
About One Eleven Grill: An inviting and stylish restaurant tucked into the heart of Red Deer just waiting for you to discover or rediscover.
Opened on the first day of November in 2011, One Eleven has been thoughtfully and skillfully preparing delicious food and drinks for Central Alberta for years.
Our passion is STEAK! We are committed to quality, serving only the very best locally-owned, grass fed Alberta Triple AAA Beef in both classic and unique cuts.
Our warm, inviting ambiance is the perfect backdrop for everything from a romantic evening, a gathering with friends and family and even a quiet business lunch during the week. We even feature live jazz every Friday and Saturday. Add in one of the best selections of wine in the region, and One Eleven will set the perfect tone for your weekend.
At One Eleven we’re committed to your total satisfaction and we celebrate the people and food of Red Deer and Central Alberta every day.
For amazing food, great music and good times with family and friends, keep One Eleven in mind.
Red Deer Chamber of Commerce accepting nominations for Business of the Year
Now Accepting Nominations for the 2019 Business of the Year Awards
The Business of the Year Awards are organized by the Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce and held annually in conjunction with Small Business Week.
The Business Awards are presented, in five categories, to exceptional businesses within the Red Deer area. All companies, Chamber members and non-members, are eligible for nomination for an award in their respective category.
“We have organizations doing extraordinary work in our community and far too often their accomplishments and charitable activities go unrecognized. Our entrepreneurs and businesses are incredibly humble so it gives of great pleasure to be able to recognize them” said Rick More, CEO of the Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce.
The Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce is now accepting nominations for the Business of the Year Awards in the following categories: 1-10 employees, 11-20 employees, 21+ employees, Young Entrepreneur and Non-Profit. Nominations can be submitted from the online nominations form. The deadline for application submission is July 26, 2019 at 4:30pm.
The Business of the Year Awards will be held on October 16, 2019 at the RDC Arts Centre & Foyer.
The Red Deer & District Chamber of Commerce is a collaborative leader in building a vibrant community and fosters an environment where businesses can lead, be innovative, sustainable, and grow.
Update: RCMP charge 3 youth with weapon possession after incident at Red Deer Middle School
The cost of the Canada Winter Games?
Alberta Sports Hall of Fame Class of 2019: Mike Rogers, Hockey Athlete
4 year old caber-tosser proves the Highland Games are in his blood!
Opinion2 days ago
The cost of the Canada Winter Games?
National1 day ago
CSIS destroyed secret file on Pierre Trudeau, stunning historians
Health2 days ago
Liberals hope to deal with HIV non-disclosure issue if re-elected: Lametti
National21 hours ago
Premier refuses to back down on plan to scrap 18,000 immigration applications
National2 days ago
NDP hopes for a jumpstart as it releases policy planks ahead of campaign
National2 days ago
First Nations, developer call for return and protection of sacred burial site
National2 days ago
AFN chief urges leaders to ensure passage of key bills for Indigenous Peoples
National1 day ago
Butterfly garden keeper manages to film large tarantula shedding exoskeleton