By Michael Haynes, Snr. Vatican Correspondent
‘I didn’t say 100% I’ll save him,’ Trump claimed on a Fox News interview last week about imprisoned Jimmy Lai. ‘I said 100% I’m going to be bringing it up, and I’ve already brought it up.’
As the trial for imprisoned businessman Jimmy Lai draws to a close, President Donald Trump stated he has “already” discussed the plight of Lai with China’s President Xi Jinping.
“I didn’t say 100% I’ll save him,” Trump claimed on a Fox News interview last week, referencing prior comments. “I said 100% I’m going to be bringing it up, and I’ve already brought it up [with President Xi Jinping], and I’m going to do everything I can to save him.”
The pro-democracy activist, businessman, and former newspaper owner Jimmy Lai remains behind bars still as his trial under Hong Kong’s draconian National Security Law (NSL) hears closing arguments.
Lai – a 77-year-old British national – was sentenced to a six-year jail term in December 2022 on the charge of “fraud.” According to news outlet Hong Kong Free Press (HKFP), at Lai’s 2022 sentencing, the judge also imposed “an eight-year disqualification order to Lai and ordered the media tycoon to pay HK$2 million in fines.”
But his current trial is for separate charges of “collusion with foreign forces” in violation of the draconian NSL that Beijing imposed on the island to suppress dissent against the Chinese authorities, under which he could face a life sentence. The trial has faced numerous delays by the Chinese authorities, but now – after being further pushed back last week due to a typhoon and over concerns about Lai’s health – closing arguments are being heard after proceedings commenced in December 2023.
The trial has been widely labelled as a show trial, including by his lawyers, with Human Rights Watch calling the charges “fabricated.”
An open letter from Doughty Street Chambers in 2023 described the “fraud” charges against Lai as “spurious,” and added that his arrest under the NSL was simply for “peaceful pro-democracy campaigning and his work at Apple Daily.”
Lai himself has pleaded not guilty to the charges against him. If the court – which comprises hand-picked judges rather than a jury in a notable break from precedent – finds him guilty, he could face life in prison.
A guilty verdict is seen by many as highly likely.
The businessman was brought into the Catholic faith by fellow Hong Kong resident Cardinal Joseph Zen, and is a strong and vocal critic of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) and its measures against freedom.
He founded the pro-democracy tabloid Apple Daily in 1995, which published criticism of the CCP that earned it the ire of the communist authorities. The newspaper became one of the leading outlets in Hong Kong prior to its forced closure by the authorities.
Prosecutor Anthony Chau has previously said that “this case is about a radical political figure … who conspired with others to bring into hatred and stir up opposition to the government and the central authorities.”
“He’s a respected guy, he’s a good guy. You can also understand, President Xi would not be exactly thrilled by doing it,” added Trump to Fox News about Lai, regarding his championing Lai’s cause to the Chinese.
Continuing, the president stated:
It was a very nasty period of time in the history of China. With all of that being said, his name has already entered the circle of things that we’re talking about, and we’ll see what we can do.
Trump made much stronger promises last year prior to his election victory when he stated that, should he win the U.S. presidential election, he would speak to China’s Xi Jinping about brining Lai out of the country. “One hundred percent, yes. I’ll get him out. He’ll be easy to get out. But we don’t have people that even talk about it.”
His latest remarks appear to downplay the certainty of his actions regarding Lai’s future.
The condition’s of Lai’s time in prison have led to international concerns about his health. Even three months prior to the start of this trial, Lai already marked 1,000 days behind bars. Now, he is approaching nearly 1,700 days.
Since his August 2020 arrest, Lai has been spending around 23 hours of every day in solitary confinement, in conditions which violate those laid out by the United Nations for the treatment of prisoners. On his brief 50 minutes allowed out of the cell, Lai is accompanied by guards in a separate pen, in contrast to other prisoners who are allowed to mix with each other or play sports.
Despite the extreme humidity and heat of Hong Kong in the summer, Lai’s cell is not fitted with any air conditioning.
Now Lai is described as having to wear a heart monitor in court following heart palpitations in recent days.
China experts and Hong Kong activists have vocally championed the cause of Lai on the international stage, as have a number of prominent Catholic clergy such as New York’s Cardinal Timothy Dolan. Shortly prior to the NSL trial starting, a number of prominent prelates called for Lai’s immediate release.
Human Rights Watch stated last Friday that the authorities should “drop the baseless charges against Jimmy Lai.”
“Holding the 77-year-old Lai in prolonged solitary detention while his health fails has been outrageously cruel,” wrote the group. “Concerned governments should press for Lai’s immediate release both for his sake and for the sake of media freedom in Hong Kong and China.”
Related