Connect with us

Great Reset

Assisted suicide activists should not be running our MAID program

Published

6 minute read

From the MacDonald Laurier Institute

By Shawn Whatley

We should keep the right-to-die foxes out of the regulatory henhouse

The federal government chose a right-to-die advocacy group to help implement its medical assistance in dying legislation. It’s a classic case of regulatory capture, otherwise known as letting the foxes guard the henhouse.

In the ā€œFourth annual report on Medical Assistance in Dying in Canada 2022,ā€ the federal government devoted several paragraphs of praising to the Canadian Association of MAID Assessors and Providers (CAMAP).

ā€œSince its inception in 2017, (CAMAP) has been and continues to be an important venue for information sharing among health-care professionals and other stakeholders involved in MAID,ā€ reads the report.

With $3.3 million in federal funding, ā€œCAMAP has been integral in creating a MAID assessor/provider community of practice, hosts an annual conference to discuss emerging issues related to the delivery of MAID and has developed several guidance materials for health-care professionals.ā€

Six clinicians in British Columbia formedĀ CAMAP, a national non-profit association, in October 2016. These six right-to-die advocatesĀ published clinical guidelinesĀ for MAID in 2017,Ā without seriously consultingĀ other physician organizations.

TheĀ guidelinesĀ educate clinicians on their ā€œprofessional obligation to (bring) up MAID as a care option for patients, when it is medically relevant and they are likely eligible for MAID.ā€ CAMAP’s guidelines apply to Canada’sĀ 96,000 physicians,Ā 312,000 nursesĀ and the broader health-care workforce ofĀ two-million Canadians, wherever patients are involved.

The rise of CAMAP overlaps with right-to-die advocacy work in Canada. According toĀ Sandra Martin, writing in the Globe and Mail, CAMAP ā€œfollow(ed) in the steps of Dying with Dignity,ā€ an advocacy organization started in the 1980s, and ā€œbecame both a public voice and a de facto tutoring service for doctors, organizing information-swapping and self-help sessions for members.ā€

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau tapped this ā€œtutoring serviceā€Ā to leadĀ the MAID program. CAMAP appears to follow the steps of Dying with Dignity, because the same people lead both groups. For example, Shanaaz Gokool, a currentĀ director of CAMAP,Ā served as CEOĀ of Dying with Dignity from 2016 to 2019.

A founding member andĀ current chairĀ of the board of directors of CAMAP is also a member of Dying with Dignity’s clinician advisory council. One of the advisoryĀ council’s co-chairsĀ is also a member of Dying with Dignity’s board of directors, as well as a moderator of the CAMAP MAID Providers Forum. TheĀ otherĀ advisory council co-chairĀ served on bothĀ the boards of CAMAP and Dying with Dignity at the same time.

Overlap between CAMAP and Dying with Dignity includesĀ CAMAPĀ founders, board members (past and present), moderators,Ā research directorsĀ and more, showing that a small right-to-die advocacy group birthed a tiny clinical group, which now leads the MAID agenda in Canada. This is a problem because it means that a small group of activists exert outsized control over a program that has serious implications for many Canadians.

George Stigler, a Noble-winning economist,Ā described regulatory captureĀ in the 1960s, showing how government agencies can be captured to serve special interests.

Instead of serving citizens, focused interests can shape governments to serve narrow and select ends. Pharmaceutical companies work hard toĀ write the rulesĀ that regulate their industry. Doctors demand government regulations — couched in the name of patient safety — to decrease competition. The list is endless.

Debates about social issues can blind us to basic governance. Anyone who criticizes MAID governance is seen as being opposed to assisted death and is shut out of the debate. At the same time, theĀ world is watchingĀ Canada and trying to figure out what is going on with MAID and why weĀ are so differentĀ than other jurisdictions offering assisted suicide.

Canada moved from physician assisted suicideĀ being illegalĀ to becoming a world leader inĀ organ donationĀ after assisted death in the space of just six years.

In 2021, Quebec surpassed the Netherlands toĀ lead the worldĀ in per capita deaths by assisted suicide, with 5.1 per cent of deaths due to MAID in Quebec, 4.8 per cent in the Netherlands and 2.3 per cent in Belgium. In 2022, Canada extended its lead: MAID now represents 4.1 per cent of all deaths in Canada.

How did this happen so fast? Some point toĀ patients choosing MAIDĀ instead of facing Canada’s world-famousĀ wait timesĀ for care. Others note a lack ofĀ social services. No doubt many factors fuel our passion for MAID, but none of these fully explain the phenomenon. In truth, Canada became world-famous for euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide because we put right-to-die advocates in charge of assisted death.

Regardless of one’s stance on MAID,Ā regulatory captureĀ is a well-known form of corruption. We should expect governments to avoid obvious conflicts of interest. Assuming Canadians want robust and ready access to MAID (which might itself assume too much), at least we should keep the right-to-die foxes out of the regulatory henhouse.

Shawn Whatley is a physician, a Munk senior fellow with the Macdonald-Laurier Institute and author of ā€œWhen Politics Comes Before Patients: Why and How Canadian Medicare is Failing.ā€

Todayville is a digital media and technology company. We profile unique stories and events in our community. Register and promote your community event for free.

Follow Author

2025 Federal Election

Carney’s Hidden Climate Finance Agenda

Published on

From Energy Now

By Tammy Nemeth and Ron Wallace

It is high time that Canadians discuss and understand Mark Carney’s avowed plan to re-align capital with global Net Zero goals.

Mark Carney’s economic vision for Canada, one that spans energy, housing and defence, rests on an unspoken, largely undisclosed, linchpin: Climate Finance – one that promises a Net Zero future for Canada but which masks a radical economic overhaul.

Regrettably, Carney’s potential approach to a Net Zero future remains largely unexamined in this election. As the former chair of the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ), Carney has proposed newĀ policies,Ā offices,Ā agencies,Ā  andĀ bureausĀ required to achieve these goals.. Pieced together from his presentations, discussions, testimonies and book, Carney’s approach to climate finance appears to have four pillars: mandatory climate disclosures, mandatory transition plans, centralized data sharing via the United Nations’ Net Zero Data Public Utility (NZDPU) and compliance with voluntary carbon markets (VCMs). There are serious issues for Canada’s economy if these principles were to form the core values for policies under a potential Liberal government.

About the first pillar Carney has beenĀ unequivocal: ā€œAchieving net zero requires a whole economy transition.ā€ Ā This would require a restructuring energy and financial systems to shift away from fossil fuels to renewable energy with CarneyĀ insistingĀ repeatedly in his book that ā€œevery financial [and business] decision takes climate change into account.ā€ Climate finance, unlike broaderĀ sustainable financeĀ with its Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) focus would channel capital into sectors aligned with a 2050 Net Zero trajectory.Ā Carney states: ā€œCompanies, and those who invest in them…who are part of the solution, will be rewarded. Those lagging behind…will be punished.ā€ Ā In other words, capital would flow to compliant firms but be withheld from so-called ā€œhigh emittersā€.

How will investors, banks and insurers distinguish solution from problem? Mandatory climate disclosures,Ā aligned withĀ the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), would compel firms to report emissions and outline their Net Zero strategies.Ā Canada’s Sustainability Standards BoardĀ has adopted these methodologies,Ā despite concerns they would disadvantage Canadian businesses. Here, Carney repeatedly emphasizes disclosures as the cornerstone to track emissions data required to shift capital away from ā€œhigh emittersā€. Without this, he claims, large institutional investors lack the data on supply chains to make informed decisions to shift capital to businesses that are Net Zero compliant.

The second pillar, Mandatory Transition Plans would require companies to map a 2050 Net Zero trajectory for emission reduction targets. Failure to meet those targets would invite pressure from investors, banks, or activists, who may pursue litigation for non-compliance. The UK’sĀ Transition Plan Task Force, now part of ISSB, provides this standardized framework.Ā Carney, while at GFANZ, advocated using transition plans for a ā€œmanaged phase-outā€ of high-emitting assets like coal, oil and gas, not just through divestment but by financing emissions reductions. ā€œAs part of their transition planning, [GFANZ] members should establish and apply financing policies to phase out and align carbon-intensive sectors and activities, such as thermal coal, oil and gas and deforestation, not only through asset divestment but also through transition finance that reduces real world emissions. To assist with these efforts GFANZ will continue to develop and implement a framework for the Managed Phase-out of high-emitting assets.ā€ Clearly, the purpose of this is to ensure companies either decarbonize or face capital withdrawal.

The third pillar is the United Nations’ Net Zero Data Public Utility (NZDPU), a centralized platform for emissions and transition data.Ā Carney insistsĀ these data be freely accessible, enabling investors, banks and insurers to judge companies’ progress to Net Zero. As CarneyĀ noted in 2021: ā€œPrivate finance is judging…banks, pension funds and asset managers have to show where they are in the transition to Net Zero.ā€ Hence, compliant firms would receive investment; laggards would face divestment.

Finally, voluntary carbon markets (VCMs) allow companies toĀ offset emissionsĀ by purchasing credits from projects like reforestation. Carney, who launched theĀ Taskforce on Scaling VCMsĀ in 2020, has insisted on monitoring, verification and lifecycle tracking. Ā At aĀ 2024 Beijing conference, he suggested major jurisdictions could establish VCMs by COP 30 (planned for 2025 in Brazil) to create a global market. If Canada mandates VCMs, businesses especially small and medium enterprises (SMEs) would face much higher compliance costs with credits available only to those that demonstrate progress with transition plans.

These potential mandatory disclosures and transition plans would burden Canadian businesses with material costs and legal risks that constitute an economic gamble which few may recognize but all should weigh. Do Canadians truly want a government that has an undisclosed climate finance agenda that would be subservient to an opaque globalized Net Zero agenda?


Tammy Nemeth is a U.K.-based strategic energy analyst. Ron Wallace is an executive fellow of the Canadian Global Affairs Institute and the Canada West Foundation.

Continue Reading

armed forces

Yet another struggling soldier says Veteran Affairs Canada offered him euthanasia

Published on

From LifeSiteNews

By Jonathon Van Maren

‘It made me wonder, were they really there to help us, or slowly groom us to say ā€˜here’s a solution, just kill yourself.’

Yet another Canadian combat veteran has come forward to reveal that when he sought help, he was instead offered euthanasia.Ā 

David Baltzer, who served two tours in Afghanistan with the Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry,Ā revealed to theĀ Toronto SunĀ that he was offered euthanasia on December 23, 2019—making him, as theĀ SunĀ noted, ā€œamong the first Canadian soldiers offered therapeutic suicide by the federal government.ā€

Baltzer had been having a disagreement with his existing caseworker, when assisted suicide was brought up in in call with a different agent from Veteran Affairs Canada.Ā Ā 

ā€œIt made me wonder, were they really there to help us, or slowly groom us to say ā€˜here’s a solution, just kill yourself,ā€ Baltzer told the Sun.ā€œI was in my lowest down point, it was just before Christmas. He says to me, ā€˜I would like to make a suggestion for you. Keep an open mind, think about it, you’ve tried all this and nothing seems to be working, but have you thought about medical-assisted suicide?ā€™ā€Ā 

Baltzer was stunned. ā€œIt just seems to me that they just want us to be like ā€˜f–k this, I give up, this sucks, I’d rather just take my own life,ā€™ā€ he said. ā€œThat’s how I honestly felt.ā€Ā 

Baltzer, who is from St. Catharines, Ontario, joined up at age 17, and moved to Manitoba to join the Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry, one of Canada’s elite units. He headed to Afghanistan in 2006. TheĀ SunĀ noted that he ā€œwas among Canada’s first troops deployed to Afghanistan as part Operation Athena, where he served two tours and saw plenty of combat.ā€Ā 

ā€œWe went out on long-range patrols trying to find the Taliban, and that’s exactly what we did,ā€ Baltzer said. ā€œThe best way I can describe it, it was like Black Hawk Down — all of the sudden the s–t hit the fan and I was like ā€˜wow, we’re fighting, who would have thought? Canada hasn’t fought like this since the Korean War.ā€Ā 

After returning from Afghanistan, Baltzer says he was offered counselling by Veteran Affairs Canada, but it ā€œwas of little help,ā€ and he began to self-medicate for his trauma through substance abuse (he noted that he is, thankfully, doing well today). Baltzer’s story is part of a growing scandal. As theĀ SunĀ reported:Ā Ā 

A key figure shedding light on the VAC MAID scandal was CAF veteran Mark Meincke, whose trauma-recovery podcast Operation Tango Romeo broke the story. ā€˜Veterans, especially combat veterans, usually don’t reach out for help until like a year longer than they should’ve,’ Meincke said, telling the Sun he waited over two decades before seeking help.Ā 

ā€˜We’re desperate by the time we put our hands up for help. Offering MAID is like throwing a cinderblock instead of a life preserver.’ Meincke said Baltzer’s story shoots down VAC’s assertions blaming one caseworker for offering MAID to veterans, and suggests the problem is far more serious than some rogue public servant.Ā 

ā€˜It had to have been policy. because it’s just too many people in too many provinces,ā€ Meincke told the Sun.ā€Æā€œEvery province has service agents from that province.’

Veterans Affairs Canada claimed in 2022 that between four and 20 veterans had been offered assisted suicide; Meincke ā€œpersonally knows of five, and said the actual number’s likely close to 20.ā€ In a previous investigation, VAC claimed that only one caseworker was responsible—at least for the four confirmed cases—and that the person ā€œwas lo longer employed with VAC.ā€ Baltzer says VAC should have military vets as caseworkers, rather than civilians who can’t understand what vets have been through.Ā 

Featured Image

Jonathon’s writings have been translated into more than six languages and in addition to LifeSiteNews, has been published in theĀ National Post,Ā National Review,Ā First Things, The Federalist, The American Conservative, The Stream, theĀ Jewish Independent,Ā theĀ Hamilton Spectator,Ā Reformed Perspective Magazine, and LifeNews, among others. He is a contributing editor to The European Conservative.

His insights have been featured on CTV, Global News, and the CBC, as well as over twenty radio stations. He regularly speaks on a variety of social issues at universities, high schools, churches, and other functions in Canada, the United States, and Europe.

He is the author ofĀ The Culture War,Ā Seeing is Believing: Why Our Culture Must Face the Victims of Abortion,Ā Patriots: The Untold Story of Ireland’s Pro-Life Movement,Ā Prairie Lion: The Life and Times of Ted Byfield, and co-author ofĀ A Guide to Discussing Assisted SuicideĀ with Blaise Alleyne.

Jonathon serves as the communications director for the Canadian Centre for Bio-Ethical Reform.

Continue Reading

Trending

X