MAiD
Conservative MP warns Canada to stop ‘wrong’ and ‘dangerous’ euthanasia expansion to mentally ill
MP Michael Cooper
From LifeSiteNews
On March 9, 2024, Medical Assistance in Dying is set to include those suffering solely from mental illness and MP Michael Cooper said Canadians ought to be ‘offered hope and help’ and ‘not death.’
Canada is set to go down a “very dangerous road in March of 2024” should it proceed with expanding euthanasia to the mentally ill, warned Conservative MP Michael Cooper, who urged the Liberal federal government to immediately “scrap” its “radical” assisted-suicide program and instead offer “hope” for the suffering.
“Unless the Liberals reverse course, Canada is set to go down a very dangerous road in March of 2024, when MAiD for mental illness becomes available,” Cooper said in a video posted to X (formerly Twitter) on Wednesday.
“There is something they (the federal government) can do. Canada doesn’t need to go ahead with this, what the Liberals need to do is follow the evidence, stop the madness, and introduce legislation to permanently scrap this radical expansion.”
Cooper then said Canadians who are “suffering from mental health issues” ought to be “offered hope and help” and “not death.”
On March 9, 2024, euthanasia in Canada, or Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD) as it is known, is set to expand to include those suffering solely from mental illness. This is a result of the 2021 passage of Bill C-7, which also allowed the chronically ill – not just the terminally ill – to qualify for so-called doctor-assisted death.
The expansion comes despite warnings from top Canadian psychiatrists who said the country is “not ready” for the coming expansion of euthanasia to those who are mentally ill, adding that the procedure is not something “society should be doing” as it could lead to deaths under a “false pretense.”
Cooper noted that the law itself is ambiguous in that it leaves open the door to anyone being approved for the grim procedure.
“It is impossible to accurately predict your immediate reality under the law,” said Cooper, adding, “The leading medical professionals said that Canada isn’t ready for two fundamental reasons.”
“The first is that in order to qualify for MAiD, someone must suffer from an irremediable disease or illness, and afterwards one must suffer from a disease or illness in which they are not going to get better, and they are in an irreversible state of decline,” he noted.
Cooper observed how medical professionals have said that suffering from mental illness can’t “accurately be predicted, and so, therefore, persons who could get better, who could go on to lead healthy and happy lives, will have their lives prematurely ended.”
He then noted that a second “fundamental problem” with expanding MAiD to those with mental illness is the difficulty to “distinguish in the case of mental illness between a rational request for aid and one motivated by suicidal ideation.”
“This is underscored by the fact that the vast majority of persons who commit suicide suffer from a diagnosable mental disorder. And you might be wondering who would qualify for MAiD in mental illness? What constitutes a mental disorder for the purpose of the law?”
As it stands now, according to a task group appointed by the Liberals that was struck to establish MAiD practice “standards,” anyone would qualify “if they suffer from a mental disorder listed in” the standards guide, which includes those who are depressed, autistic, or having addictions issues.
Cooper said that the standards as written are “radical” as well as “dangerous” and “wrong.”
The mental illness expansion was originally set to take effect in March 2023. However, after massive pushback from pro-life groups, conservative politicians and others, the Liberals under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau delayed the introduction of the full effect of Bill C-7 until 2024 via Bill C-39, which becomes law next year.
The delay in expanding MAiD until 2024 also came after numerous public scandals, including the surfacing of reports that Canadian veterans were being offered the fatal procedure by workers at Veterans Affairs Canada (VAC).
When it comes to MAiD, more Canadians are dying from the procedure every year. Indeed, a recent Statistics Canada update admitted to excluding euthanasia from deaths totals despite being the sixth highest cause of mortality in the nation.
The number of Canadians killed by lethal injection since 2016 now stands at 44,958.
Stopping euthanasia expansion still possible, says pro-life advocate
Recently, LifeSiteNews reported on how pro-euthanasia lobbyists want Canada’s assisted suicide via lethal injection laws to be extended to drug addicts, which critics warn could lead the nation down a dangerous path nearing “eugenics.”
Recent attempts by the Conservative Party of Canada (CPC) to stop the expansion of MAiD have failed.
MPs in the House of Commons voted down a private members’ bill introduced by CPC MP Ed Fast that would have repealed the expansion of euthanasia laws to those suffering from mental illness.
However, according to LifeSiteNews contributor and pro-life advocate Jonathon Van Maren, Canadian Justice Minister Arif Virani noted that the “Trudeau government is considering delaying the expansion once again.”
Virani recently told The Canadian Press that the Liberal government is “weighing our options” about expanding MAiD in March while currently assessing what the joint parliamentary committee and medical experts are telling them.
“We’ll evaluate all of that comprehensively to make a decision whether we move ahead on March 17 or whether we pause,” he noted.
For respectful communication with Justice Minister Arif Virani:
Email: [email protected]
Constituency Office phone: 416-769-5072
Parliamentary Office phone: 613-992-2936
Health
US podcaster Glenn Beck extends a lifeline to a Saskatchewan woman waiting for MAiD
From LifeSiteNews
Jolene Van Alstine was approved for euthanasia after tiring of waiting years for surgery in Canada
A Canadian woman is looking to die by state-sanctioned euthanasia because she has had to endure long wait times to get what she considers to be proper care for a rare parathyroid disease.
The woman is Jolene Van Alstine, whose condition, normocalcemic primary hyperparathyroidism (nPHPT), causes her to experience vomiting, nausea, and bone pain.
As noted in a recent CBC report, Van Alstine claims she is not able to get proper surgery to remove her parathyroid in her home province of Saskatchewan, as there are no surgeons in that province who can perform that type of surgery.
She has said her “friends have stopped visiting me” and she is “isolated” and living “alone lying on the couch for eight years, sick and curled up in a ball, pushing for the day to end.”
“I go to bed at six at night because I can’t stand to be awake anymore,” she said.
As a result of her frustrations with the healthcare system, Van Alstine applied for Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD). She was approved for the procedure on January 7, 2026.
Saskatchewan Health Minister Jeremy Cockrill met with Van Alstine last month to try to see if he could help her, but what they talked about remains confidential.
“The Government of Saskatchewan expresses its sincere sympathy for all patients who are suffering with a difficult health diagnosis,” the government said.
As reported by LifeSiteNews, over 23,000 Canadians have died while on wait lists for medical care as Prime Minister Mark Carney’s Liberal government is focused on euthanasia expansions.
A new Euthanasia Prevention Coalition report revealed that Canada has euthanized 90,000 people since 2016, the year it was legalized.
Americans offering Jolene surgery help now say they have made contact with her
Van Alstine’s story has gone viral on the social media platform X, catching the attention of well-known American personalities, some who have claimed they can help her.
“If there is any surgeon in America who can do this, I’ll pay for this patient to come down here for treatment,” Glenn Beck wrote Tuesday on X.
“THIS is the reality of ‘compassionate’ progressive healthcare. Canada must END this insanity and Americans can NEVER let it spread here.”
According to Beck in a subsequent X post, he has had “surgeons who emailed us standing by to help her.”
“We are in contact with Jolene and her husband! Please continue to pray for her health,” he wrote on X.
“Will update more soon.”
As reported by LifeSiteNews recently, a Conservative MP’s private member’s bill that, if passed, would ban euthanasia for people with mental illness received the full support of the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition.
Lobby groups have pushed for MAiD to be expanded to minors.
Desiring to expand the procedure to even more Canadians, former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government sought to expand from just the chronically and terminally ill to those suffering solely from mental illness. The current Liberal government appears to want to continue with the MAiD regime.
However, in February, after pushback from pro-life, medical, and mental health groups as well as most of Canada’s provinces, the federal government delayed the mental illness expansion until 2027.
Great Reset
Proposed ban on euthanasia for mental illness sparks passionate debate in Canada’s Parliament
From LifeSiteNews
“When a person is standing on the edge, the role of a responsible nation is to pull them back.”
Conservative MP Tamara Jansen’s Bill C-218—the “Right to Recover Act”—was debated in Parliament on Friday. The legislation would ban euthanasia for those suffering solely from a mental illness, which was legalized in 2021 with the Trudeau government’s Bill C-7, but subsequently delayed. It is set to come into effect in 2027, pending a parliamentary report.
Tamara Jansen led with a passionate and powerful speech highlighting the desperate need for Bill C-218; Conservative MP Andrew Lawton gave a supporting speech in which he shared his own experience with a nearly successful suicide attempt. Two Liberal MPs and a member of the Bloc Quebecois pushed back in support of euthanasia for mental illness.
Jansen moved that Bill C-218 be read the second time and referred to committee, and asked her fellow parliamentarians to imagine someone’s son, in his forties, struggling with a painful illness and struggling with addiction, depression, and anxiety. He is supported by his family, she said, and they are doing their best but struggling. When he finally gets a psychiatrist appointment, he hopes he might finally get real help.
“He is vulnerable, scared and hanging on by a thread,” Jansen said. “At that appointment, instead of being offered a plan to get him stable, MAID is raised as an option. The assessment moves ahead, and before he ever receives proper support for his mental health or addictions, he is approved. His MAID provider is the one who drives him to the place where his life is ended. This is someone’s son who needed help, not a final exit.”
“Believe it or not, this actually happened here in Canada, and this is where we are headed if we do not act,” she emphasized. “Unless this Parliament chooses a different path, Canada will allow MAID for people whose only condition is mental illness. That means men and women struggling with depression, trauma or overwhelming psychological pain could be steered toward death by a system that too often cannot offer timely treatment, consistent follow-up or even basic support.”
Jansen noted that when Parliament last debated assisted suicide, mental illness was not included in the core discussion—but that it was added “in a last-minute Senate amendment to Bill C-7.” Since then, Canadians from all walks of life have spoken clearly against this dangerous expansion. “Psychiatrists across Canada, including the chairs of psychiatry at all 17 medical schools, have told us plainly that there is no reliable way to predict when a mental illness is irremediable, which is a requirement in the MAID law,” she reminded her colleagues.
READ: Canadian broadcaster’s positive coverage of disability advocate’s euthanasia sends terrible message
“We must ask: who receives suicide prevention and who is guided toward MAID?” she asked. “If a person suffering from depression calls a crisis line tonight, do we encourage them to hold on or do we quietly redirect them to an assessor? What principle decides the answer? What medical test? What ethical standard? There is none. That is because the very feelings that drive someone to seek MAID, hopelessness, despair or the belief that they are a burden, are the same signals that every suicide prevention worker is trained to treat as a cry for help.”
Jansen also noted that Canada’s planned expansion has been condemned in the international community. “International human rights experts have raised the alarm, including the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which has urged Canada to step back. It warns that our trajectory risks discriminating against people with disabilities and mental illness and recommends repealing this expansion entirely. This is what Bill C-218 would do.” She cited several heartbreaking examples from Ontario’s MAID death review committee findings:
They describe a man who had cancer. I will call him Bill. Earlier in his illness, he had briefly mentioned MAID, as frightened patients tend to do. By the time he was assessed, he was delirious, confused and heavily sedated. His own medical team made it clear that he no longer had the capacity to make major decisions, yet a MAID assessor shook him awake, took the faint motion of lips as consent, withheld sedation, obtained a rushed virtual second opinion and ended his life that same day. Bill was not stable. Bill was not capable. He did not understand what was happening.
Alana Hirtle, the Liberal MP for the Nova Scotia riding of Cumberland-Colchester, responded by attempting to divert from the issue. She told Jansen that her father died by assisted suicide in August 2024, after suffering from “four different types of cancer over five years,” and stated that she “fully supported his choice” and that she “supported the process as it took place and was there throughout it.” She then asked if Jansen had voted for the “initial legislation”; Jansen told her she was not an elected MP at the time.
Claude DeBellefeuille, a Bloc Quebecois MP, then claimed that he was “stunned” by what he had heard, stating that Jansen had been misleading “by claiming that the law allows for medical assistance in dying when major mental illness is the sole underlying disorder” when the “member knows that in 2027, a joint committee of members and senators will make a decision based on the recommendations of the Department of Health.” While he did, somewhat surprisingly, agree that “the medical community is not ready and will probably not be ready in 2027,” he insisted that Jansen “has simply found a way to assert her opposition to medical assistance in dying.”
“We simply do not have the medical grounds to declare that a life is beyond hope,” Jansen responded. “We have already seen cases where people were approved for MAID not because their condition was truly irremediable but because they lacked housing, treatment or basic support. That is not medicine; that is a system misreading desperation as destiny. … When a person is standing on the edge, the role of a responsible nation is to pull them back.”
Juanita Nathan, the Liberal MP from Pickering-Brooklin, gave a speech essentially reiterating the government’s talking points. More research is needed, she said, but fundamentally the “panel concluded that the existing Criminal Code safeguards, when supported by the development of MAID practices standards and the implementation of other recommendations, are adequate to allow for safe provision of MAID to people whose sole underlying medical condition is a mental illness.”
MP Andrew Lawton recounted his own suicide attempt, in which he almost lost his life and spent seven weeks in the hospital, during which he was resuscitated multiple times and on life support. He noted that on that “horribly dark and sad December day in 2010,” he could never have imagined that he would one day be standing in the House of Commons, happily married with a successful career. It is that experience, he said, which spurs him to speak so forcefully for Bill C-218—because “if the laws that are coming into force in 15 months had been there 15 years ago, I would probably be dead right now.”
When Bill C-218 was introduced, Lawton launched the “I Got Better” campaign, inviting Canadians to share their own stories.
He shared several with the House—while a number of the Liberal MPs talked loudly with each other across the House, even laughing out loud at each other. He shared the story of an Ottawa lawyer, who feared using MAID if depression should return. He shared the story of a man who struggles with mental illness and has attempted suicide and is afraid of what he might do if MAID is available. A woman who had been in a long-term abusive relationship told him that she would have used MAID if it had been available.
Lawton detailed several other stories and reminded his colleagues of testimony they had previously heard. “Dr. John Maher testified before Parliament that 7% of those who attempt suicide die by suicide,” he said. “That means that 93% of people who, at one or multiple points, want to end their life eventually get over that. The success rate of MAID is 100%. By design, this is a policy that will give up on people.”
Lawton’s closing lines summed up the stakes. “These are real people,” he said. “There are faces to this. If Bill C-218 does not pass, people will die. We have a right and a duty to stand up for those who need it. I will be proudly supporting this bill, and I thank my colleague so much for introducing it.”
You can support Bill C-218 and submit your own story to MP Andrew Lawton here.
-
National20 hours agoLiberal bill “targets Christians” by removing religious exemption in hate-speech law
-
Business2 days agoThe EU Insists Its X Fine Isn’t About Censorship. Here’s Why It Is.
-
Business2 days agoCanada invests $34 million in Chinese drones now considered to be ‘high security risks’
-
Bruce Dowbiggin2 days agoWayne Gretzky’s Terrible, Awful Week.. And Soccer/ Football.
-
Business17 hours agoLooks like the Liberals don’t support their own Pipeline MOU
-
Economy2 days agoAffordable housing out of reach everywhere in Canada
-
Health2 days agoCDC Vaccine Panel Votes to End Universal Hep B Vaccine for Newborns
-
Business1 day agoThe Climate-Risk Industrial Complex and the Manufactured Insurance Crisis
